If the city approves the plan to replace Macy's with 680 homes this coming Monday, how soon will the store close? The city's own paperwork points to a slow answer. The special joint hearing of the Staff Hearing Officer and the Architectural Board of Review is set for Monday, November 9, 2026, at 3 p.m. in the David Gebhard Public Meeting Room at 630 Garden Street. The city says that once the project is approved, the applicant may apply for building permits. Approval allows a permit application. It doesn't start construction.
For Hope Ranch households that shop at La Cumbre Plaza and Five Points every week, the more useful thing to know is how the mall's redevelopment is split. It is moving as two separate projects, on two separate parcels, with two separate owners, and they have reached very different stages. Most of what has changed at La Cumbre in 2026 came from ordinary tenant turnover, with no hearing involved.
What Monday's Hearing Actually Decides
The city's project page for The Neighborhood at State & Hope describes the proposal as demolishing the Macy's building and its parking on the 8.8-acre north end of the plaza, at 3805 State Street and 110 S. Hope Avenue. In their place would go a 680-unit mixed-use rental project that includes moderate-income, very low-income and market-rate units, plus retail, dining, commercial and public spaces. Two city bodies will rule on three items on November 9:
- A Tentative Subdivision Map. It would divide the 14.9-acre legal lot into two parcels. One is the 8.8-acre development site. The other holds the rest of the existing shopping center, which the city says "could be redeveloped in the future."
- A CEQA exemption. The city has determined that, with conditions needed for General Plan consistency, the project qualifies for the statutory exemption created by Assembly Bill 130, which Governor Newsom signed on June 30, 2025.
- Project Design Approval from the Architectural Board of Review, based on the architectural drawings.
The city's posted planning timeline lists a step called "Ready for building permits" with an estimate of one year. That estimate covers paperwork only. It doesn't give a construction start date. The city also says that after City Council voted unanimously in August 2024 to negotiate a possible development agreement, which could have secured more affordable housing than currently proposed, "no agreement was reached." The project is moving forward under the city's Average Unit-Size Density Incentive Program and State Density Bonus law.
The neighbor notice lists the owner as MCP Santa Barbara LLC, with Gelaré Macon of Flowers & Associates as the applicant contact. The development team on the project's own site is the father-and-son pair Jim and Matthew Taylor. That site describes six distinct buildings, two levels of underground residential parking, a park, plazas and paseos, small local retail spaces, eateries and a restaurant. Several items in the plan would change how people get around the plaza: a new right-turn lane from State onto South Hope, a Class 1 bike lane linking State and Hope, and a new connection between La Cumbre Road and Hope Avenue. Those are proposals. The hearing is where they start to become conditions.
Two Halves of the Mall on Two Different Timelines
The south end of the plaza is a separate project with a different owner. The former Sears store and auto center at 3845 State Street is the subject of La Cumbre South Homes, a 443-unit rental proposal. In 2023, Noozhawk reported that the Taylors owned about 15 acres facing State Street and that Riviera Dairy, a family-owned company, owned the other half of the mall.
| North end: Macy's site | South end: former Sears | |
|---|---|---|
| Address | 3805 State St. and 110 S. Hope Ave. | 3845 State St. |
| Proposal | 680 rental units, mixed use | 443 rental units |
| Owner / applicant | MCP Santa Barbara LLC, the Taylor team | Riviera Dairy Products, presented by Kennedy Wilson |
| Last public milestone | Joint SHO/ABR hearing, Nov. 9, 2026 | ABR concept review, Nov. 10, 2025, continued indefinitely |
| What operates there now | Macy's | Miss Daisy's Consignment & Auction House |
The south project's last public milestone was a rough one. The Santa Barbara Independent reported that the Architectural Board of Review unanimously continued the project indefinitely after its November 10, 2025 concept review. The board asked for connecting courtyards, a paseo, a more cohesive design for the farmhouse-style amenities building, and story poles on at least two corners along La Cumbre Road. The same report quoted Vice Chair Dennis Whelan: "This misses the point of what genuine Santa Barbara architecture is." On the city's project page, the latest stated status for that project is still application completeness review.
Taken together, the north half is about to enter its permit phase, while the south half still has design work ahead of it, and the middle of the plaza has no application at all.
Macy's Is Still Open Today
The Macy's store locator still lists the 3805 State Street store with a full weekly schedule, and the La Cumbre Plaza directory still names Macy's among its major retailers, along with Pottery Barn and Williams Sonoma. The commonly repeated closing date of 2028 comes from a January 2023 Noozhawk report that said the store "won't be around after 2028." That report is almost four years old. The store's own locator page still shows regular hours, so treat 2028 as an old report rather than a confirmed schedule.
Bristol Farms is the grocery the plaza's directory lists. The hearing doesn't change what is on the shelves there or anywhere else in the mall.
What Changed This Year Without Any Hearing
The changes Hope Ranch shoppers have actually seen at La Cumbre in 2026 were ordinary tenant moves that needed no city approval:
- Mendocino Farms opened at 3851 State Street on June 30, 2026, the day after a soft-opening dinner, according to the Independent.
- Islands Fine Burgers & Drinks closed its La Cumbre location on September 27, as Edhat reported. Some plaza directory pages still list it.
- The Sears building is occupied now. Miss Daisy's Consignment & Auction House runs its consignment and auction business in the former Sears at 3845 State Street, the same building the 443-unit plan would replace.
- Five Points, across Hope Avenue, is getting PopUp Bagels at 3925 State Street in the former Blaze Pizza space. In August, the News-Press reported a "mid-fall" opening target with signage already up. Check before you go.
The plaza's dining page also lists Backyard Bowls, Chipotle, Lure Fish House & Oyster Bar, Panda Express, Starbucks, Wingstop and See's Candies. Since the Islands listing has outlasted the restaurant, a single directory entry isn't proof that a business is open.
How the Public Can Weigh In Before Monday
The city's neighbor notice describes in-person testimony.
- In person. Testimony is taken at 630 Garden Street when the Chair calls for it, and individual comments are typically limited to two minutes. The notice names a physical room and doesn't mention a remote option.
The notice says the partial plans and staff report will be posted through the city's ABR and SHO pages. Complete plans can be viewed in person at the 630 Garden Street planning counter on Monday, Tuesday and Thursday from 8:30 a.m. to noon, and on Wednesday from 8:30 a.m. to 5 p.m. The city says most of the plans aren't posted online. The current proposed site plan, however, is available as a PDF on the city site.
The Plaza and Its Edges This November
Normal November events continue around the hearing date:
- Sunday, November 8, 10 a.m. to noon. A free Arroyo Burro Beach cleanup with Explore Ecology meets at the Watershed Resource Center, 2981 Cliff Drive. Participants get a Santa Barbara Shellfish Co. chowder coupon.
- Sunday, November 15, 2 to 5 p.m. Free live music with Society Jazz at Miss Daisy's in the old Sears building.
- Friday, November 20, 5 to 8 p.m. The free LCCCA Art Walk runs on the third Friday of each month and includes three galleries, refreshments and live music. The next one is December 18.
To reach the plaza without the car, the Independent reported in May that the county finished a roughly one-mile Modoc Multi-Use Path segment linking the Obern Trail to the Las Positas path. That created a continuous bike and walking route from Arroyo Burro Beach toward Isla Vista. The proposed Class 1 bike lane between State and Hope would add a connection at the plaza end, if it survives into the final approvals.
Upper State Street is changing on several separate timelines, and the property questions around it depend on those details. If you would like to talk through what the State & Hope and La Cumbre South proposals could mean for a Hope Ranch home you own or are considering, Maureen McDermut & Associates is glad to help. Schedule a private consultation.